Why are dairy cows skinny?

22

June 10, 2013 by dairycarrie

I have often had people ask me why my cows are so skinny. Online I have seen people make claims that dairy cows are skinny because dairy farmers are milking them all the time and causing their bodies to burn out. Of course I have a different take on this information.  Let’s take a look at some reasons why dairy cows are skinny.

1. Dairy cows are not beef cows. While a cow is a cow in the end, the traits we have bred dairy cows for versus what we want from beef cows are different. Just like a Labrador doesn’t look like a Greyhound, a dairy cow doesn’t look like a beef cow. You won’t see a Labrador winning any races and your pet Greyhound isn’t equipped to handle freezing water. A beef cow does give milk but not the amounts that a dairy cow produces. A dairy breed won’t convert feed into muscle as quickly as a beef breed. An overly skinny cow, beef or dairy is a sign of a big problem. A dairy cow carrying too much fat will also cause a lot of health problems. Different breeds have different qualities and that plays a major role in why a cow looks skinny.

meth lab

greyhound running

2. Dairy cows put their calories into the milk they make not fat stores. Dairy cows on our farm eat a lot of feed each day but instead of converting the feed into muscle and fat like a beef steer would, a dairy cow pours the calories into milk making. When a woman breastfeeds her caloric intake needs to be higher than it would be normally, this is because her body is using it’s calories to make milk.

3. Hair styling. The whole internet is abuzz talking about the “Fluffy Cow” craze. A fluffy cow is a beef breed that has been bred to have lots of hair. When these animals are shown they have hours and hours of time spent on them grooming their coats to be super fluffy. Fluffy hair makes them look much larger than they really are. When we show dairy cattle we do the opposite. A dairy cow is shown with the cow equivalent to a buzz cut, called body clipping. For showing a dairy cow we want the judge to see her angles and her body, extra hair would cover that up so before a dairy cow is shown she gets a full body hair cut. Beef or dairy, these show cows have hours of attention poured on them before they show to make sure that they are looking their absolute best in the ring.

Fluffy cow vs a dairy cow

This is a beef cow with it’s hair fluffed. AKA a “Fluffy Cow”. Without the hair, this cow would look much smaller.

This is a dairy cow (actually this specific photo is a composite that shows what an ideal Holstein could look like)

This Holstein dairy cow has been clipped for show.  (This specific photo is a composite that shows what an ideal Holstein could look like)

So in the end when we look at why a cow looks skinny it’s important to understand the difference between what a dairy cow has been bred for and what a beef cow has been bred for. Both beef and dairy farmers use a tool called body condition scoring (BCS) to determine if their cows are the appropriate weight. Good information about using BCS to determine a cow’s level of health can be found here for dairy and here for beef. 

FluffyCow

Enhanced by Zemanta

22 thoughts on “Why are dairy cows skinny?

  1. Lee Fresh says:

    Oh, Yay to find your site! I arrived here after Googling (yup) “is a bony cow healthy?” because I had just seen a picture of a dairy cow at a show and bless it’s heart it looked emaciated (with chubby udders I noticed). I assumed it was okay or it wouldn’t be at a show, lol, but I HAD to find out more information for my curiosity. I’m *cough* 56 years old and it’s the first time I’d noticed how bony dairy cows are. Not that I’ve seen many…most likely only on a dairy farm tour decades ago and they were all hooked up to machines. Your comparison of dogs was a perfect picture for we-who-are-unfamiliar with differences in cows. It’s still pretty scary looking to those of us used to seeing full-bodied bovines :D I’m one of those people who has called to report a possible starving or abused animal, so it’s a good thing I didn’t see a skinny cow in real life. (sidetracked and off topic, I love Skinny Cow ice cream sandwiches).

    Cows are delightful creatures – I was surprised to learn that they are very curious. :)

    And now I know.

    Thank you so much for your site.

  2. However…. If one has a Holstein cow who is nursing her own calf, she has a much smaller, much more manageable udder, and much more weight (if fed side by side with a cow on the milk line).

    The analogy of breastfeeding women is not correct. Yes, a nursing mother of any species will need more calories to produce the milk for her offspring. But to use a breastfeeding woman as an equitable example would need to see her pumping (not nursing) only twice, maybe 3 times per day and keeping up with the needs of 4 and a half babies, without supplementation. Under those circumstances, her breasts will become exceedingly painful and large, and yes, she will lose a lot of weight because she simply could not eat enough calories to maintain that much lactation.

    If you google, Holstein cow with calf, you’ll see many images of healthy-weight Holsteins.

    • dairycarrie says:

      A Holstein cow nursing her own calf and with moderate quality feed will produce more milk than one calf can drink. This leads to mastitis and other problems. They have been bred for milk production.

      Maybe rather than getting all of your information from google you should talk to farmers instead? Although from the tone of your comment I suspect that you’re not interested in learning because you’ve made up your mind.

      • My apologies if I had a “tone”. It was not my intent. And I’m not sure why you think that I don’t want to learn and haven’t spoken with farmers. I thought I was simply bringing up another possibility. That’s what debate is all about– finding out good reasons on both sides. If you have a better argument– I’m more than happy to hear it! I hope I’ve never made up my mind until I have heard all sides of an issue and then have taken the time to carefully weigh the arguments. Even then, if someone has facts or suggestions I haven’t heard of or considered before– please, I’m happy to hear them!

        I have been around many farms and farmers in my lifetime– and lived next door to and was friends with one for many years.

        I’ve raised orphaned calves as well.

        Yes, milking breeds have been bred for milk production. What I’m saying is that the milk production (in large quantities– not for one or even two calves) is what causes the weight to all go away from their ribs and spine and into their udders for this production. I suspect that if you took a Hereford cow and put her on the milk line (yes, I’m aware that she wouldn’t produce as much as a dairy breed), she will produce much more milk than her calf could handle.

        It’s the same as women who pump extra to donate to a milk bank.

        I know that mastitis is a huge problem on the milk line, but I’ve never heard of a dairy cow who is nursing her own calf (and not being machine milked on the side), producing more milk than her calf is capable of taking. Mammary glands are incredible things– they produce just what the baby needs. Not to say it’s never happened– but from the people I know who’ve allowed dairy cows to raise their own calves– they had no problems.

        You’ve accused me of not wanting to learn– do you not believe that this is something to even consider?

        And, by the way, google (which in this case I used only for a photo to show a healthy-weight, nursing Holstein) is used by many people, from professionals on down, for researching. Of course one does not believe everything automatically– but that’s true for all areas of life.

        • dairycarrie says:

          I apologize. To me, your original comment read as someone who was against dairy farming. I have a lot of people comment here who want nothing more than to see me out of business. When I read your comment I believed that it came from someone who was anti dairy.

          This post is meant to show the difference in body build between beef and dairy breeds. A dairy heifer, before she ever milks will not carry weight the same as a beef heifer. If you milked the Herford and she produced double what she normally would, she wouldn’t look like a Holstein. Milking alone is not what makes a dairy cow look thinner than a beef cow. On our farm we have some crossbred cows that have a dual purpose breed, like Normande in them. They aren’t as thin as our Holsteins despite the fact that they milk very well.

          A Holstein heifer on our farm that has never produced milk in her life gives 40-60lbs of milk on the second day of her lactation. A single newborn calf couldn’t eat half of that. Eventually a cow would decrease production, if in the mean time she didn’t end up with mastitis from not being milked out completely.

        • Dairy cows produce, on average, 6-7 gallons a day (around 55 pounds of milk). I don’t know a calf that can drink that much, considering a birth weight should be around 85 pounds! A calf allowed to drink as much milk as it desires will consume a little over 20 pounds a day. Additonally, although this breed of cow looks “skinny”, nutritionists will highly monitor body condition score for the breed, as she will produce the maximum amount of milk, be the healthiest, etc., when she is at an optimal condition. I learned the hard way myself that I become extremely ill when I don’t consume enough food to keep up with weight loss and stress during calving time! Glad you are participating in these discussions!

  3. I LOVE your blog!
    I had the sheriff’s office called on me last summer because someone driving by thought my Jersey was too skinny. The officer that the caller talked to was someone I went to high school with, and also knows a little about cows. He told the caller that my animals are well taken care of, and that she is thin because she is a dairy cow. While I am very glad that whoever called actually talked to someone who knew something- I was also glad that someone who had a concern actually called the authorities, instead of ignoring it or making an ‘under-cover video’.

  4. LisaA says:

    Thanks for this article! There are people arguing on Craigslist right now about the condition of some dairy cows for sale. Some say they are “emaciated,” and the owners should be charged with neglect, others say they are just fine, with nice full udders. It looks like they are actually nice healthy dairy cows! I like the comparison of labs to greyhounds. That is very helpful.

  5. Jenna says:

    Thank you for the article- we have had uneducated neighbors call the authorities on the other neighbor’s cows that were being “STARVED” for sure she just knows they are it

  6. sahara says:

    I have a jersey and she is so perfect not to skinny. she is perfect

  7. […] first at how bony the dairy cows look, but it’s totally normal and totally okay.  Check out Dairy Carrie’s post here for […]

  8. […] first love apart from my wife and children are the dairy cows, because we’ve been doing dairy cows at Worthy Farm for 150 years,” said Eavis. “If I thought for a moment badgers would […]

  9. Christy says:

    Years ago I worked for the county Animal Welfare League. I had to educate them on the differences between beef/dairy breeds of cows/goats because of the well meaning but misguided people who would call to report a skinny cow or goats, and everyone but me were all “city folks” and didn’t know the difference themselves! And I used the same dog analogy (THAT, they understood!) Only difference was, I used a greyhound and a bulldog as examples..lol

    • Alene says:

      I had the same trouble with someone calling on me with an old horse. When animal control came they had no idea. Showed all the food we had for the horses. And that the horse that I was called on was 30 plus in age. Had to teach them what an older horse can look like.

  10. Peter Draper says:

    As always Carrie – an excellent explanation. Kudos!

  11. Erica says:

    I have been asked that question so many times and never thought about the breed of dog comparison. I will borrow this for the fairs coming up! Thank you!

  12. toggpine says:

    Great explanation! This is true in our dairy goat world too.

  13. threecollie says:

    Great answer to a question I have been asked, I think maybe about a million times, at shows and fairs!

  14. Excellent topic! When I take teachers on tours of dairy farms, they often have this question. Thank you for addressing it.

No spam, just an email when I post a new blog.

Join 1,100 other subscribers

Categories

%d bloggers like this: